If They Wanted To, They Would—But Would They Really?
One of the most viral dating mantras in recent years is “If they wanted to, they would.” It’s simple, it’s catchy, and on the surface, it seems like empowering advice. But when we scratch deeper, relationships aren’t always black and white. Human psychology, past trauma, cultural norms, and even technology-driven communication patterns complicate how people show effort in dating. Let’s break down why this phrase isn’t always the ultimate truth—and how you can approach modern love with more clarity.
The Appeal of the Phrase
For many, the phrase feels like a comforting reality check. It reminds us that consistent effort is non-negotiable in healthy relationships. If someone truly values you, they’ll prioritize communication, make plans, and show up. But while this idea helps people set boundaries, it also risks oversimplifying dating behavior.
Psychology Behind Effort in Dating
- Anxiety & Avoidance: Someone might genuinely want to pursue you, but their attachment style makes them hesitant to initiate.
- Fear of Rejection: People often misinterpret silence as disinterest, when in reality, it’s fear holding them back.
- Different Love Languages: Some show care through actions, others through words. If you expect one and get the other, effort may feel “invisible.”
- Past Experiences: Someone who has been ghosted or hurt may take longer to open up, even if they’re genuinely interested.
Social Media and Dating Apps Complicate Effort
Dating in 2026 is shaped by apps, texting habits, and digital culture. A person might like your Instagram posts, send memes, or watch your stories without directly asking you out. Does that count as effort? The digital gray zone blurs intention and makes “If they wanted to, they would” harder to apply.
Signs Someone Genuinely Wants To
If you’re unsure about someone’s intentions, here are indicators of genuine effort:
- They initiate plans, not just late-night texts.
- They follow through on what they say.
- They show consistency, not just bursts of attention when convenient.
- They make space for you in their real life, not only online.
Why Effort Isn’t Always Obvious
It’s important to remember: someone may want to but feel restricted. Cultural expectations, gender roles, or personal insecurities may prevent them from expressing interest in the way you expect. For example, many men are socialized to always initiate, while women may fear being labeled “too forward.” The balance between interest and action is more complex than a single phrase suggests.
How to Rethink This Phrase
Instead of taking “If they wanted to, they would” as absolute truth, try reframing:
- “If they value me, they’ll show up consistently—even if it looks different from my expectations.”
- “If I’m confused, I’ll communicate directly instead of decoding mixed signals.”
- “If it feels like pulling teeth, maybe they’re not ready or not right for me.”
Empowering Yourself in Modern Dating
The phrase can still empower you if you use it as a filter. Don’t overinvest in someone who repeatedly leaves you uncertain. Recognize effort when it’s there, but also have compassion for the fact that not everyone expresses desire in the same way. Modern dating is about balancing empathy with boundaries.
Final Thoughts
“If they wanted to, they would” shouldn’t be your only dating compass. Instead, use it alongside self-respect, emotional intelligence, and open communication. In a world where relationships are influenced by mental health, social media, and cultural shifts, effort looks different for everyone. Your task is to spot genuine consistency—and not settle for breadcrumbing or emotional labor imbalances.
Related Reads on Ichhori: